
Elizabeth Holmes in You Can See Everything. Photo: A24
(174 minutes, 15, in cinemas from today)
Contains mild spoilers
There is no other film – let alone a documentary – which has occasioned such anticipatory excitement at the post-Covid box office. Co-directed by Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder – the latter also essentially a co-star – You Can See Everything documents the final 34 days before Theranos fraudster Elizabeth Holmes began her 11-year prison sentence, and it’s had us queueing round the block. We want to see the promised total transparency for ourselves. Can you really see everything?
Such is the intense fascination inspired by both Fielder and Holmes that either would have been a draw on their own. He is the Canadian improv-provocateur behind acclaimed TV docu-comedies Nathan for You and The Rehearsal. She’s the young female self-made billionaire turned disgraced health-tech CEO who’s already been the subject of multiple podcasts and documentaries, an acclaimed book, and a drama series, The Dropout, for which Amanda Seyfried won an Emmy. Now the onscreen combination of the two, in an eyeball-to-eyeball showdown, has proved irresistible.
Fielder’s main truth-detection tactics seem to involve lurking in the shadows, prolonged eye contact, and a general imperviousness to social niceties
Indeed, initially the film pivots almost entirely around the shaky fulcrum of this relationship. Is Elizabeth Holmes lying? And is Nathan Fielder the man to find out? Holmes and her hotel-heir partner, Billy Evans, insist they have nothing to hide. To prove it, they’ve not only consented to being filmed, but also invited Fielder to move into the spare room at their seafront Airbnb.
Fielder’s main truth-detection tactics seem to involve lurking in the shadows, prolonged eye contact, and a general imperviousness to social niceties, which allows him to ask direct questions and then sit in the awkward silence which follows. Is it effective? Not particularly. But it is fascinating to watch, and frequently funny besides. He earns his keep by offering up some alternative explanations for Holmes’s behaviour, which sit somewhere between culpable mendacity and total butter-wouldn’t-melt (blood-wouldn’t-coagulate?) innocence. Could it be that some neurolinguistic abnormality has rendered her unable to distinguish the truth from a lie?

L-R: Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans and Nathan Fielder in You Can See Everything. Photo: A24
That’s just the first half, though. Once Holmes and her baby blues are locked up, and no longer available for Fielder to gaze into interrogatively, the film-makers are forced to widen the parameters of their investigation to consider the system that makes women like her simultaneously easy to victimise, and able to play the perpetual victim. And who better to locate that line than the woman who once played Holmes herself?
The casting of Amanda Seyfried – an official secret until the film’s mid-October US release – adds yet another creamy layer to this millefeuille of meta. Now we get to watch Fielder watching Seyfried watching him watching Holmes watching Seyfried appearing as Holmes on TV. It is Seyfried who suggests that Fielder’s feelings for Holmes – pity? something more? – might be clouding his judgment. And it’s through Seyfried’s own gigantic blue eyes that we get the most compassionate view of Holmes: as a mother soon to be separated from her very young children, and as a woman possibly lost in a controlling, coercive relationship. (Something both she and Evans deny.)
Holmes’s character never comes fully into focus, only receding further from view as the film progresses and extreme close-ups are replaced by a long-angle lens, shooting from the regulation 50ft outside prison perimeters. But I’ll tell you who definitely is deceiving us, and knowingly too: two mischievous little guys named Nathan and Lance.
Though you wouldn’t have known it from the hype surrounding release, they’re hardly the first documentarians to wittily blur real with reconstructed and scripted with staged. The Palme d’Or-winning Iranian film-maker Abbas Kiarostami was doing so back in 1990, with his vérité-style showbiz-scam-courtroom-drama-doc Close-Up. Hell, they do it weekly on Real Housewives of Wherever and every other reality television mainstay. The best documentaries have always drawn attention to the omissions, framings and other artifices entailed in their construction; and of the two disciplines, at least fiction film-making is honest about the fact it’s all made up.
So what can you see? The pores at the end of Elizabeth Holmes’s nose and also the snot inside it? Sure, get a good look. Full-frontal male nudity? Yes, that too. By combining substantial journalism with salacious silliness and occasional flurries of surrealist whimsy, You Can See Everything manages to engage both Fielder fanatics and the more casual crowd for a continuously riveting 174 minutes. The most tangible take-home, however, may be that it’s impossible to tell if someone’s lying to you simply by maintaining eye contact for a really long time. But you can have fun trying.

Ellen E Jones is the Nerve’s film critic. A writer and broadcaster, her book Screen Deep: How Film and TV Can Solve Racism and Save the World (Faber) won the Kraszna-Krausz Prize. She co-hosts the BBC’s flagship film and TV programme, Screenshot, on BBC Radio 4, and won the Broadcasting Press Guild’s Presenter of The Year 2025
