
Stand Up to Racism protesters outside Nathan Cofnas’s lecture in Oriel Square, Oxford. Photo: Leon Neal/Getty Images
During the Q&A session at Nathan Cofnas’s talk at Oxford University on Tuesday, I asked him if he would like to say sorry to the family of Jason Arday.
He refused, saying “the implication is I have done something wrong”. At one point in his answer, he said: “Why am I still talking about him?” Then he asked me: “Have you read my Substack?” Seconds later, the room burst into applause.
I first got in touch with the Oxford Reform Society, in February, when they had just set up, for an article I was writing about the rise of an organisation called Students for Reform and those who back Nigel Farage. Maybe they remembered this, as they agreed last week to let me attend their talk by Cofnas, the self-described “race realist”, which had the title: “Is DEI undermining higher education?”
The event, held in an old library-cum-theatre at Oriel College, drew an audience of 40 people, despite chairs being set up for 100. Outside, hundreds of anti-Cofnas protesters were successfully barricading the entrances to the college. This meant many ticket-holders were unable to enter, although Cofnas's personal security guards and the college proctors ushered attendees in and out. There were only three people of colour in the room, and I was the only woman of colour.
Cofnas, who is an academic, is semi-suspended from Ghent University due to an ongoing investigation into public statements he made in July accusing Professor Jason Arday of plagiarising his PhD thesis and biography, igniting a febrile media storm. In August, Arday was found dead. No formal review has found Arday guilty of the plagiarism Cofnas accused him of.

The demonstration outside Oriel College. Photo: Jordan Reynolds/PA Images via Getty Images
Although he was relatively unknown before the summer, Cofnas’s body of work stretches back beyond Arday. In a podcast clip that went viral during the media frenzy, Cofnas said: “After the revolution, I will be the head of eugenics and race science at Harvard.” (Cofnas and his supporters have accused the media of taking this, and other claims of his, including “in a meritocracy… the number of Black professors would approach zero”, out of context.)
The talk at Oxford was a semi-structured, quasi-academic lecture, billed as an examination of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI). But instead, Cofnas spent most of the hour explaining the history of the “race equality thesis” (the claim that races ought to be treated equally because they possess the same socially relevant traits) and what he described as a dubious scientific consensus underpinning it. “DEI ideology, also called wokeism, is the ideology of taking the equality thesis seriously,” he said.
“One of the mechanisms of higher education is DEI or affirmative action, on the assumption that people have the same average potential,” he explained. His “race realist” perspective however, is that differences cannot be corrected for, because they are genetic. He argues that if the governing factor were nature and not nurture, then people like Jason Arday, who was Cambridge’s youngest Black professor, would not be “treated like a genius”.
“Once you’ve put unqualified people in these positions, people will accuse you of racism, no matter how black and white the issue is – no pun intended,” he said.

Throughout, he also alluded to his own victimhood. ‘We have a mob outside trying to murder us just for talking about this,’ he claimed
I had to pay close attention to follow Cofnas’s arguments. He has a dense, droning delivery, and the audience could be seen looking at their phones until the odd inflammatory buzzword jerked them to attention. He used phrases like “liberal”, “blank slate-ism”, and “philosophy” pejoratively and vaguely. He also accused “liberals” of using "euphemisms", arguing that words such as “morality” and “phrenology” were employed to shut down discussion of the topic.
“Africans have the lowest brain size, followed by whites, and east Asians having the largest,” he said. This was simply “brain science”.
Some of his claims were just inaccurate. At one stage he attributed the wrong publication date to an academic paper that he believed marked the last time hereditarianism had been taken seriously, claiming it was 1959 when it was a decade later.
Throughout, he also alluded to his own victimhood, as a result of a “taboo” placed on his ideas. “We have a mob outside trying to murder us just for talking about this,” he claimed. He said he believed that “fancy institutions” were “lying through their teeth” to protect Arday.
While criticising higher education institutions, he also lamented his exclusion from them, saying: “One of the consequences of shutting down people like me is you enhance the credibility of people like [far-right streamer] Nick Fuentes. If people like me were allowed to operate within mainstream institutions, if I were treated more like a normal academic…” He tailed off.

The event was organised by the Oxford Reform Society. Photo: Jordan Reynolds / PA / Getty
During the Q&A session, members of the LGB Alliance, a trans-exclusionary organisation, asked Cofnas if anything could be learned from gender-critical academics, to which Cofnas responded yes, adding that they “put up much more of a fight”.
When I then asked Cofnas whether he would like to apologise to Arday’s family, he responded: “The implication is I've done something wrong by pointing out corruption from a powerful figure who sought power and fame [and] we shouldn't criticise powerful figures because something bad happened. Why am I still talking about him?” That was when he pointed me to his Substack.
Other attendees at the event included Edward Dutton, a prominent YouTuber with a “race science” channel, and Andy Ngo, a rightwing influencer.
I talked to some of the audience before Cofnas began speaking. Dutton told me he was not concerned by the fact that the Reform society had organised the event, and, when I put it to him, said he was not aware that the President of the society had accused Jewish people of “promoting Satan’s plan”. “That’s not the same as calling them the devil,” he told me.
An older attendee, when asked if he agreed with Cofnas’s views, replied: “[Intelligence] is like a bell curve. You can get very high intelligence – I work with a great Jamaican fellow – but the average score for Africans is 85."
Two others suggested that the presence of some races in the public sector was impeding national productivity, adding: “We should get rid of the Equality Act.”
After the event Oriel security personnel attempted to herd attendees to an available exit, as several of them were still blocked.
Near one gate, a harmonica rendition of the antifascist song Bella Ciao could be heard.
“How bizarre!” someone from the event observed.
